- 1 n8vi's AVR-tuned 2-meter double-conversion superhet project
- 1.1 Project back on hold
- 1.2 Remaining tasks
- 1.3 Path through the radio
- 1.4 Other, slightly less thought-out bits of the design
- 1.5 Alternate Design
n8vi's AVR-tuned 2-meter double-conversion superhet project
Project back on hold
Project was on hold as I tried to increase my knowledge to understand what I'm doing. I took the MITX online electronics course, 6002x (http://6002x.mitx.mit.edu), which took 100% of my free time. I couldn't recommend it more.
The class completed a couple of weeks ago, and I started thinking again about how to get this project moving forward. I think I'm going to be looking again at the coupling between the LO and first mixer now that I have a better idea of what other people are doing: lowpass filter followed by buffer amplifier.
I may do a subproject to test my understanding: a direct-conversion HF receiver of some sort. This will allow me to test out some of the design ideas without the additional variables of VHF.
But for now, the project is back on hold, as I am highly distracted by the 12.5" dobsonian telescope I'm building.
If you see any glaring stupid in this design, please let me know. It's my first RF circuit. Hell, it's really my first analog circuit.
I've just updated the schematic image to clarify a lot of things and add a couple bits, so some of the text below may not make sense anymore. I'll clean that up soon.
It's a hodgepodge of bits of schematic I've stolen from other people's projects. The only bits really missing are the microcontroller and the power for the two ICs (which will probably need some filtering). Stay tuned for Eagle bits.
- The first LO connection to the first mixer is completely wrong. FIND NEW SOURCE. Perhaps a redesign is in order? I like this design, it's cheaper.
- Footprint the LM380 and the MCP4131.
- Deal with each IC's power and bypass capacitor requirements.
- The AD9859 needs 1.8v. FIND A GOOD SMT 1.8v REGULATOR.
- I'll be using the SMT 5v regulators I already have for the AVR, it's max232, the digital pot, the SA602 and the SA605
- The LM380 looks like it will do fine on an unregulated 12v supply. It won't work on 9v though, so 9v batteries are out.
- Add test points to both the in phase and quadrature inputs to the FM demod mixer.
- Perform schematic capture in eagle. Perhaps add more test points.
- Order parts.
- Reread every document I got stuff from and every datasheet seeking board layout clue.
- Reread that one document that is all about board layout.
- Layout board in eagle.
- Verify parts against footprints.
- Verify board layout again, going through all those previously mentioned docs
- Order board.
Path through the radio
What follows is in approximate order of path through the radio (there are a few unions, such as the separate LO and IF inputs to the second mixer).
First LO (AD9859)
I dug around through all of Analog Devices' DDS chips, and this one is the cheapest that does the frequency I'm interested in. It also seems to be fairly conservative in it's current draw. It's datasheet is here. Information on amplitude shaping can be found on page 16, and information on the full scale control resistor, the resistor that sets output current, can be found on page 12. Note to self: don't forget, DAC output must be referenced to AVDD, not AGND (page 12 of datasheet).
First LO Connection to First Mixer
Well, it looks like my notes (in my original schematic/doodle/hen scratchings) say "from WA5BDU", so I'll try googling that in a minute here ...
Slide 24 of http://ozarkcon.com/wa5bdu_06/wa5bdu_ozarkcon_06.ppt. Yup. There it is right there. Although, I thought the original document specifically mentioned using an AD9850. Seems to be what my notes indicate.
Oh look, he's using a board with an HF filter on it, not a bare DDS. THIS PART NEEDS ATTENTION, IT'S WRONG. This may be a good time to redesign with a lower frequency cheaper DDS and an SA602-based frequency multiplier.
Something to read: http://www.g4jnt.com/144MHzDCReceiver.pdf
Front End Filter and First Mixer (SA602)
This is the bit between the antenna and pins 1 and 2 of the first mixer, the SA602. This whole piece of schematic was taken from an article called "Junk-Box Converters for 6 and 2 Meters" (log in to paid ARRL membership required prior to clicking this link) by Rod Kreuter, WA3ENK in the January 1997 issue of QST (someone else has made bits of schematic available here). Most of the rest of what's connected to the SA602 comes from this article, besides the first LO. The SA602's datasheet can be found here, and information on connecting an external LO is on page 4.
I don't get it - to me it looks like a parallel resonant circuit with a resonant frequency of 210.179MHz, with the antenna input fed into not quite the middle of the capacitance. Don't mind me, I've been spending a lot of time reading this years ARRL handbook ...
Anyway, BNC connectors.
First IF, connection to second mixer
This was taken from a double conversion superhet of somewhat simpler design on page 9 of this pdf. This PDF is awesome and is where I got most of what I've learned in this design. It is linked again later down this page, probably multiple times.
Second LO (Xtal)
Per AN1994, this appears to be a fundamental-mode colpitts oscillator.
Note to self: check browser history of 10/23.
I may have converted caps on a different frequency LO to reactances, changed frequency to 10.245 and converted back to capacitances. I may even have done this to a datasheet example.
Second mixer, FM demodulator (SA605)
The second mixer and FM demodulator is an SA605 chip. It's datasheet can be found here.
This is the bit that takes the signal we're inputting into one side of the FM demodulator, throws it 90° out of phase, then feeds it into the other side. As far as I understand, the SA605 then mixes these two signals to demodulate FM.
This place has IF cans, but looks tedious to purchase things from.
This place too.
Right, so the Audio level out of the SA605 is nominally 150 mV RMS across a 100k resistor (with a 15pF capacitor in parallel for FM de-emphasis) (page 4 for spec, page 6 for diagram). We'll pretend the capacitor isn't there since the cap's lowest reactance at any frequency we care about is over 3 Mohms at 3KHz. which in parallel adds up to 97.3 KOhms.
So, 150mV over 100k is ... 1.5 uA? So that's .2 uW? sheesh ...
And my speaker's rated input power is 700mW at an 8 ohm impedance (it's an SMS-1308MS-R from PUI)
So that's a 65.4 dB gap to bridge if I understand correctly ...
I should check the output impedance of the SA605 and figure out if I need some sort of transformer, or perhaps to use a different resistor ... Is the output impedance set by the resistor if the SA605 truly has a current output? I can only assume the resistor is there because it's a current output...
This is the point where I give up and steal other people's ideas
That volume control pot will be hard to find in a form factor I don't despise. Almost makes me want to put a digital pot there, if one exists that can handle 1W.
RV09AF-20-20K-A15 ? RV09AF-40-20K-A100K? PTV09A-2020F-A104?
dear future self, you're not handling power across the speaker, but out of the mixer. It's minuscule. Stop trying to find a 1W audio taper pot
WHAT THE HELL WHY NOT this is mouser's cheapest SPI digital POT. (I want to keep the i2c bus clear for other modules to control the radio as a whole)
Other, slightly less thought-out bits of the design
This is where I hash out bits of the design that I think are important, but I haven't devoted the brainpower or googlefu to yet. Most of the following will probably be more thought out after I have a mostly working schematic.
In (the oft-referenced) this pdf, there was a test point for the second IF, and I liked the idea, so I kept it. I've added test points for the first IF, the first LO, the second LO, and may add both sides of the quad tank among other things. I assume a similar or higher resistor value than the one at the second IF will suffice in these places.
I once beheld a card from a cisco ONS fiber node which had the most delightful oscilloscope-attachable test points and I knew I must have them. They were nothing more than surface mountable tiny loops of metal, but they were perfect, and just small enough to be un-hobbyist-makeable.
I have no idea how much is necessary or where, and haven't even thought about it. I may unmask bits of the ground plane throughout the board just in case I need to solder copper foil to it or whatever. ooh, or jam wires into through holes and wrap copper foil on that like a fence ...
I've read a couple documents on this, such as this one. I'll worry more about it when I have a complete schematic and move into the board design phase.
Testing and debugging
Besides looking for certain waveform appearances at certain test points (but not what voltages to look for), I have no idea what I'm doing here. Once again, this pdf may have some guidance.
Links to wade through for me to find my sources
http://www.oocities.org/hagtronics/2_meter.html I don't think I got anything here besides inspiration.
https://scholar.sun.ac.za/bitstream/handle/10019.1/16362/kellerman_modular_2004.pdf Has a 10.245 LO that looks like mine, and I remember reading it at some point.
http://www.stanford.edu/class/ee133/appnotes/AN1983.pdf I just found this, so it's not something I got any part of this circuit from, but it might be a cheaper way to get VHF LO (with a cheaper DDS).
http://www.qsl.net/n9zia/spec/Spectrum_Analyzer.pdf This url looks familiar but the document itself doesn't at all. Lop off a chunk of that url to find some other interesting projects and some tedious rants.
Doing it properly
Of course, the proper way to do this would be with math and a thorough understanding of what's going on. I have a pretty good understanding of what's going on, but here's some resources anyway, perhaps to help me understand what I did if I actually make it work:
Pretty good tutorial on smith charts. This guy's web site has some other good stuff too.
Another possibility, besides a dual conversion superhet, is an HF receiver with a 2-meter down converter bolted on the front end. The difference here is where the VFO is - in the superhet, it's the first LO, in the HF plus down converter, it's the second. Big advantage here is that now the VFO is lower in frequency, and in DDSes that makes a huge difference in price. Just compare the AD9859 at $21.45 to the AD9833 at $9.79. Also, the 9833 can run at 5v, thus doesn't need another voltage regulator. And the 9833 is something I definitely can solder.
Anyway, part of my design goals in this radio is something that can be made cheaply, so I'm going to take a break and read the filter section of the ARRL Handbook and think about whether that's what I want to do.
Though lowering the frequency of the VFO sounds great, the IF following the VFO has to be high enough in frequency to allow for the tuning range desired (1/2 the range, to be precise). This is the whole reason I chose a double conversion design in the first place, because the SA605 is more stable at 455 KHz. That only allows for 910KHz tuning without running into an image frequency, and I need 4MHz.
So the basic upshot of this is that adding a fixed frequency downconverter up front doesn't allow for me to remove a stage. I still have to have a double conversion superhet after that. So, for now, I think I'll be focusing on the superhet without the downconverter in front.